
WHY MAKE THINGS
PART 2/3
Things
Part One of this essay explored how modern culture encourages us to defer to existing interpretations, rather than trust our own emerging thoughts and feelings. It reflected on how speed, optimisation, constant commentary, and the pressure and seductive technological availability for a sense of certainty weaken our ability to stay with ambiguity long enough for something genuinely new to take shape. It also began to explain Nowing Collective’s aim: to create conditions where curiosity and ideas can be honoured and explored rather than prematurely edited, optimised, or abandoned. So, what is being protected, and what begins to form, when curiosity is nurtured?
There are countless artworks, discoveries, novels, projects, songs, and ideas the world has never encountered - not because they lacked brilliance or meaning, but because the conditions that might have allowed them to emerge were interrupted, absent, or never fully formed. And while, yes, it is clear that the tangible outcomes of ideas - whether constructive or disruptive - hold great value in their potential to impact and contribute to culture in a material sense, it is not only what is materially lost that troubles us.
Nowing Collective recognises that curiosity’s concrete outcomes are not the only place in which value sits. Indeed ideas are the seeds which produce real things - new forms, new solutions, new ways of building and seeing. However, ideas do not only hold their value in what they become, but rather also in what happens to a person through the act of staying with the ambiguity of that idea - the ambiguity of curiosity - even briefly, and even without resolution. Following our curiosity and staying with an idea changes something less visible than the outcome - the process reorganises attention. It changes relation; to time, to what feels meaningful and to where we place value.
The process of honouring our curiosity shifts what can be noticed and what can be connected with. And in doing so, has the potential to shape a culture - not through finished products, but through people who are more attentive to what they are drawn toward. Not because curiosity always leads somewhere visible. But because the process of staying with our curiosity has the capacity to reshape what a life - or a culture - is able to hold.
Conditions
If ideas matter in this way, then we ask: what makes it possible to stay with them long enough for something to take shape?
Maria Montessori began her work in the early 1900s in Rome, working with children who had been labelled as unable to learn within traditional systems. What she noticed was not a lack of capacity, but a lack of conditions that allowed attention to settle.
In one of her early classrooms, children were given simple, carefully designed materials and then left alone to engage with them. There were no constant instructions and no pressure to move at a set pace. What followed was that the children would return to the same task for long periods of time, repeating, refining, and concentrating without being prompted.
What she observed was not discipline in the conventional sense, but rather sustained attention arising naturally when interruption was removed. From this, a distinction began to form in her work - not between discipline and freedom, but between interruption and continuity.
When curiosity is met with too much intervention, too much correction, too much expectation, too much speed … it begins to fragment. Not because the curiosity disappears, but because it is never given time to stabilise into something sustained. And once that fragmentation becomes normal, attention itself starts to feel unreliable - as though it is something to manage, rather than something to trust. However, in the right conditions, something becomes clear: attention naturally follows what it is drawn toward. It does not need to be forced, but rather needs to be protected long enough to reveal its own direction.
This reframes the role of environment as not just background to thought, but rather what determines whether thought is allowed to continue becoming, or whether it is constantly reset before it can develop into anything more than its first appearance.
Attention
“Most often attention is confused with a kind of muscular effort. If one says to one’s pupils: ‘Now you must pay attention,’ one sees them contracting their brows, holding their breath, stiffening their muscles. If after two minutes they are asked what they have been paying attention to, they cannot reply. They have not been paying attention. They have been contracting their muscles… Attention is an effort, the greatest of all efforts perhaps, but it is a negative effort.” - Simone Weil, Waiting for God
Having looked at Montessori’s exploration of the external conditions that allow curiosity to hold, we now turn to Weil’s focus on the internal state required to remain with it.
Weil suggested that what is commonly understood as attention is often closer to some kind of strain: an effort to force concentration into existence through pressure or control. But she argues that attention, in its true form, is something else entirely. For Weil, attention requires openness rather than force. The ability to remain present to something without immediately trying to resolve, categorise, or master it.
Weil argues that attention is a question of receptivity, rather than concentration. A willingness to remain open to what we are drawn toward, to stay with it through an almost inevitable period of uncertainty, and to follow it long enough for something to emerge.
Sustained attention changes the quality of perception itself.
The more capable a person becomes of remaining attentive, the more capable they become of noticing beyond habit, impulse, expectation, or the immediate pressure to conclude. As Weil suggests, attention is not only cognitive, but relational. A way of meeting the world with enough stillness for something real to appear.
And this is what Weil meant by describing attention as a “negative effort.” Not an effort of force, control, or trying harder, but almost the opposite: an effort not to rush in too quickly and not to immediately fill uncertainty with certainty. Not to force conclusion onto something still in the process of forming, but to allow it the space to reveal more of itself. Not to do more, but rather do less.
And if we look to modern culture, in which attention is continually redirected toward immediacy, reaction, performance, and interruption - our thoughts are expected to become outcomes very quickly. Our curiosity is expected to justify itself through visibility or usefulness. There is little patience for the unfinished.
But it’s precisely here - in the incomplete, uncertain, difficult-to-articulate first appearance of an idea - that the possibility of something becoming real begins. Real not only in material outcome, but in a way that feels meaningful and authentic to the person staying with it. Not through force, but through the ability to remain with something long enough for it to reveal more of itself.
The third and final part of this essay will seek to explore the role community (or, the collective) plays in our experience of creativity and curiosity, and how Nowing Collective seeks to contribute to the kinds of shared conditions in which ideas, attention, and thought are able to deepen rather than be displaced at the point of emergence.