top of page
78.png

WHY RETURN MAKES IT REAL

PART 3/3

Return

​

Part of what these essays have been circling is the possibility that deepening our relationship to ourselves - and to the way we encounter the world - may not always come through discovering something previously unknown, but rather through returning to a form of knowing that we have lost regular contact with due to the conditions and rhythms of modern life.​

In this sense, the question of knowing becomes less about acquiring knowledge or discovering something entirely new - and more about remaining in relationship with what already exists.

This is why repetition matters - not because human beings fail to understand something the first time they encounter it, but because understanding is fragile. We forget. We have glimpses of seeing clearly, then our vision becomes blurry again. Our attention shifts and perspectives that once felt obvious become muddied by habit, distraction and the overwhelming pace of modern life. And because of this - what matters often requires returning to.

 

​

Repetition

​

In Religion for Atheists, Alain de Botton writes about religion from a perspective that is not necessarily concerned with belief or theology, but with the structures and rhythms religion historically provided within everyday life. The way religious traditions created repeated spaces for people to return to, to come back and keep certain ideas, values, and ways of seeing a constant in their daily lives.

​

Weekly gatherings. Shared songs. Recurring prayers. Rituals repeated across months, years, sometimes entire lifetimes - carrying with them stories, ideas, griefs, hopes, moral questions, and small shared moments of our flawed, frightening and beautiful human experiences.

​

Part of what he suggests is that these structures may have mattered not only because they taught people something once, but because they returned people to the same questions and perspectives again and again. Underlying this is a simple observation: people are forgetful.

​

Not only in the practical sense, but emotionally and existentially. We forget what matters to us. We lose contact with perspectives that once made life feel coherent or meaningful. We drift away from ways of seeing ourselves and the world that, at one point, may have felt grounding or clarifying.

There are many areas of life where this feels obvious. De Botton points out that no one expects to attend one language class and leave fluent, or go to one gym session and emerge utterly jacked. We understand instinctively that some forms of development happen slowly, through repetition, practice, and continued engagement over time. But emotionally, creatively and philosophically - we often seem to expect something different.

​

We expect immediate transformation. Immediate clarity. If something does not fundamentally alter us after one encounter, we assume it has failed or that it was never meaningful in the first place. However, many - if not most - meaningful ideas do not arrive through sudden revelation at all. They become meaningful - gradually. Through return. Through engagement. Through hearing something at different moments in life and understanding it differently each time. Through certain thoughts, questions, or perspectives slowly becoming integrated into the texture of everyday life itself.

 

​

Rituals

​

In The Disappearance of Rituals, Byung-Chul Han explores ritual not as ceremony, but as the repeated forms and structures that once gave rhythm and continuity to collective life. Shared meals. Weekly gatherings. Seasonal traditions. Familiar routines. Repeated gestures and communal pauses that people returned to over time.

​

These rituals did not only organise activity. They helped organise experience. They created recurring points of orientation within life. Temporal markers that allowed people to feel situated within time, within community, and within a continuity larger than the immediate present moment - ironically by inhabiting the present moment, communally.

​

But Han suggests that many of these rhythms have weakened within contemporary culture. He suggests that in their place has emerged a culture increasingly organised around immediacy: constant communication, continuous updates, rapid consumption, endless novelty, perpetual movement from one moment to the next. He suggests that perhaps what disappears alongside ritual is not only tradition, but a certain depth of experience.

​

Han makes the case that without repeated structures of return, moments struggle to accumulate into meaning. Experiences pass quickly before they are fully absorbed and attention moves continuously, but rarely settles long enough for continuity to form.

​

Days begin to blur together. And while people become surrounded by more stimulation - they often feel less anchored within their own lives. Less rooted in meaning, belonging and being.

Because when there are fewer shared rhythms and less continuity in our lives, there are also fewer occasions that return us to the same people, feelings, ideas, and ways of being over time.

Part of what rituals once offered was not only belief or structure, but repeated experiences of collective return. If we look to weddings, funerals, baptisms, seasonal gatherings, familiar songs, repeated meals, festivals, recurring ceremonies that people moved through together across years and generations - even for those who are not religious - there can still be a feeling within these moments of being briefly reconnected - to other people, to time passing, to memory, to something shared.

​

Ideas, feelings, and forms of curiosity rarely deepen through isolated moments alone. More often, they deepen through continued collective contact. Through being revisited, reconsidered, spoken about again, carried collectively, and slowly integrated into the way people live and relate to one another.

 

​

Collective

​

We are not in an ideas desert, but rather a conditions desert - lacking the rhythms that sustain a relationship with our inner thoughts and feelings. It’s not that we don’t know, it’s that it’s easy to avoid, be distracted from and forget what we absolutely do know. It’s not simply feeling our very human leanings toward curiosity, but remaining close enough to it for it to continue unfolding without running from the pressure to commit to exploring what we are drawn toward. And sure, to allow it to unfold into the possibility of something material - however, perhaps even greater than this, the possibility of allowing it to unfold into meaning!

​

Meaningful forms of knowing seem to emerge precisely through these slower, intentional conditions and processes. Through repeated attention. Through ongoing conversation. Through returning again and again to something not yet fully resolved. Not looking to replace, to refine, to rework something - but to stay with it long enough to become something authentic and true to an individual and their experience.

​

And this is part of what Nowing Collective hopes to contribute to. Not fixed answers, but shared conditions in which curiosity, attention, and ideas are given enough continuity to deepen.

This autumn, Nowing Collective will be opening its doors to shared space where people can return to repeatedly. We are creating conditions where thoughts, feelings and curiosities do not immediately need to become outcomes. Through shared resources, materials, reading, creative prompts, art, music, gatherings, and ongoing conversation, Nowing Collective strives to create a community in which people are able to remain in closer contact with their curiosity, attention, and their own ways of knowing. Not in isolation, but together. Not through speed or certainty, but through return, conversation, continuity, and shared attention over time.

bottom of page